Lewis Carroll's Four Riddles

Introduction

In Phantasmagoria, and Other Poems (1869) and later in Rhyme? and Reason? (1883) Lewis Carroll included four riddles. The first two were double acrostics; the last two, charades. Here I collect their solutions. If you would like to correct or extend them, please write!

The First Riddle

No. I. was written at the request of some young friends who had gone to a ball at an Oxford Commemoration—and also as a specimen of what might be done by making the Double Acrostic a connected poem instead of what it has hitherto been, a string of disjointed stanzas, on every conceivable subject, and about as interesting to read straight through as a page of a Cyclopaedia. The first two stanzas describe the two main words, and each subsequent stanza one of the cross lights.

Here is the text of the riddle:

There was an ancient City, stricken down
  With a strange frenzy, and for many a day
They paced from morn to eve the crowded town,
        And danced the night away.

I asked the cause: the aged man grew sad:
  They pointed to a building gray and tall,
And hoarsely answered Step inside, my lad,
        And then you'll see it all.


Yet what are all such gaieties to me
  Whose thoughts are full of indices and surds?
x2 + 7x + 53
        = 11 / 3.

But something whispered It will soon be done:
  Bands cannot always play, nor ladies smile:
Endure with patience the distasteful fun
        For just a little while!

A change came o'er my Vision—it was night:
  We clove a pathway through a frantic throng:
The steeds, wild-plunging, filled us with affright:
        The chariots whirled along.

Within a marble hall a river ran—
  A living tide, half muslin and half cloth:
And here one mourned a broken wreath or fan,
        Yet swallowed down her wrath;

And here one offered to a thirsty fair
  (His words half drowned amid those thunders tuneful)
Some frozen viand (there were many there),
        A tooth-ache in each spoonful.

There comes a happy pause, for human strength
  Will not endure to dance without cessation;
And every one must reach the point at length
        Of absolute prostration.

At such a moment ladies learn to give,
  To partners who would urge them over-much,
A flat and yet decided negative—
        Photographers love such.

There comes a welcome summons—hope revives,
  And fading eyes grow bright, and pulses quicken:
Incessant pop the corks, and busy knives
        Dispense the tongue and chicken.

Flushed with new life, the crowd flows back again:
  And all is tangled talk and mazy motion—
Much like a waving field of golden grain,
        Or a tempestuous ocean.

And thus they give the time, that Nature meant
  For peaceful sleep and meditative snores,
To ceaseless din and mindless merriment
        And waste of shoes and floors.

And one (we name him not) that flies the flowers,
  That dreads the dances, and that shuns the salads,
They doom to pass in solitude the hours,
        Writing acrostic-ballads.

How late it grows! The hour is surely past
  That should have warned us with its double-knock?
The twilight wanes, and morning comes at last—
        Oh, Uncle, what's o'clock?

The Uncle gravely nods, and wisely winks.
  It may mean much, but how is one to know?
He opes his mouth—yet out of it, methinks,
        No words of wisdom flow.

Solution by H. Cuthbert Scott:

QquadraticC
UundergoO
AalarmM
SstreamM
IiceE
IinterimM
NnoO
SsupperR
AarenaA
NnightT
III
TtwoO
YyawnN

Arena is doubtful and many alternatives have been suggested. Some have also suggested alternatives for stream (stoicism?).

Elsewhere the solution commemoration, monstrosities has appeared. It is clearly wrong.

The Second Riddle

Carroll wrote the second poem after seeing Ellen Terry in Hamlet. The poem has six stanzas, of which the first gives the answer to the whole riddle:

Empress of Art, for thee I twine
  This wreath with all too slender skill.
Forgive my Muse each halting line,
  And for the deed accept the will!

O day of tears! Whence comes this spectre grim,
  Parting, like Death's cold river, souls that love?
Is not he bound to thee, as thou to him,
  By vows, unwhispered here, yet heard above?

And still it lives, that keen and heavenward flame,
  Lives in his eye, and trembles in his tone:
And these wild words of fury but proclaim
  A heart that beats for thee, for thee alone!

But all is lost: that mighty mind o'erthrown,
  Like sweet bells jangled, piteous sight to see!
Doubt that the stars are fire, so runs his moan,
  Doubt Truth herself, but not my love for thee!

A sadder vision yet: thine aged sire
  Shaming his hoary locks with treacherous wile!
And dost thou now doubt Truth to be a liar?
  And wilt thou die, that hast forgot to smile?

Nay, get thee hence! Leave all thy winsome ways
  And the faint fragrance of thy scattered flowers:
In holy silence wait thy appointed days,
  And weep away the leaden-footed hours.

The obvious solution to the whole is Ellen Terry. The remaining words are probably:

EengagementT
LloveE
LliarR
EeavesdropperR
NnunneryY

Ophelia's father Polonius is the eavesdropper. Liar is from Hamlet's Doubt truth to be a liar, which appears in the following stanza. But the third word could also be lover. The last stanza paraphrases Hamlet's line Get thee to a nunnery.

The Third Riddle

Here is the text of the third riddle:
The air is bright with hues of light
  And rich with laughter and with singing:
Young hearts beat high in ecstasy,
  And banners wave, and bells are ringing;
But silence falls with fading day,
And there's an end to mirth and play.
        Ah, well-a-day!

Rest your old bones, ye wrinkled crones!
  The kettle sings, the firelight dances.
Deep be it quaffed, the magic draught
  That fills the soul with golden fancies!
For Youth and Pleasance will not stay,
And ye are withered, worn, and gray.
        Ah, well-a-day!

O fair cold face! O form of grace,
  For human passion madly yearning!
O weary air of dumb despair,
  From marble won, to marble turning!
Leave us not thus! we fondly pray.
We cannot let thee pass away!
        Ah, well-a-day!

Carroll writes of this riddle:
No. III was written after seeing Miss Marion Terry perform in Mr. Gilbert's play of Pygmalion and Galatea. The three stanzas respectively describe My First, My Second, and My Whole.
This shows that the solution is Gala, Tea, Galatea.

The Fourth Riddle

Here is the text of the fourth riddle:
My First is singular at best:
    More plural is my Second:
My Third is far the pluralest—
So plural-plural, I protest
    It scarcely can be reckoned!

My First is followed by a bird:
    My Second by believers
In magic art: my simple Third
Follows, too often, hopes absurd
    And plausible deceivers.

My First to get at wisdom tries—
    A failure melancholy!
My Second men revered as wise:
My Third from heights of wisdom flies
    To depths of frantic folly.

My First is ageing day by day:
    My Second's age is ended:
My Third enjoys an age, they say,
That never seems to fade away,
    Through centuries extended.

My Whole? I need a poet's pen
    To paint her myriad phases:
The monarch, and the slave, of men—
A mountain-summit, and a den
    Of dark and deadly mazes—

A flashing light—a fleeting shade—
    Beginning, end, and middle
Of all that human art hath made
Or wit devised! Go, seek her aid,
    If you would read my riddle!

The solution is imagination (I + magi + nation).

Bibliography

Lewis Carroll, Phantasmagoria, and Other Poems. London, Macmillan, 1869.

Lewis Carroll, Rhyme? and Reason? London, Macmillan, 1883.

H. Cuthbert Scott, The Best Acrostics, Strand Magazine 30 (1915 Dec.), 722–728. [Reference from Singmaster, infra. But volume 30 appeared in 1905, not 1915.]

Martin Gardner, The Universe in a Handkerchief: Lewis Carroll's Mathematical Recreations, Games, Puzzles, and Word Plays. New York, Copernicus, 1996. (ISBN: 038794673X)

David Singmaster, Some Unsolved Riddles, Gathering for Gardner 8, 2008 <Microsoft Word document>


Col. George Sicherman [ HOME | MAIL ]